Review: Fed. R. Civ. Pro. and others


Cliff Maier of WaffleTurtle Software has written several iPhone apps that give you the text of commonly used parts of the U.S. Code.  As a litigator, the one I find the most useful is FRCP, a $1.99 $2.99 app that gives you the full text of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, so I will discuss it first.  I list below several other apps from Cliff Maier including “Bankruptcy” — an app that iPhone J.D. reader John Rogers told me is indispensable to his bankruptcy law practice.

The interface of FRCP is simple.  Start the app and you are presented with Titles I through XI (plus a link to the Hague Conventions on service abroad, taking evidence abroad and civil procedure).  Tap on a title and you see a list of all of the rules under that title.  Tap on a rule to see the full text of the rule (for shorter rules) or a list of the subsections that you can tap for the full text of a subsection.


The app has a useful search feature.  For example, if you search for the term “summary judgment” you see a list that includes not only subparts of Rule 56 (the summary judgment rule) but also Rule 41(a)(i)’s provision that a plaintiff may voluntarily dismiss an action without a court order by filing a notice of dismissal before the opposing party serves either an answer or an MSJ.  The app starts to search as you type each letter of your search terms.  This is good because you don’t even have to type a complete word to find something, but the downside is that the app does become unresponsive for a second or two while it is searching and you are trying to type.  [UPDATE 12-11-2008:  Version 1.7 of FRCP substantially improves this, as the developer notes below in his comment.]

When you are looking at a rule, you can also tap a button at the bottom left to e-mail the text of the rule to someone.  It is handy to e-mail a rule to yourself so that you can cut-and-paste it into a brief that you are drafting on your computer.

The layout of this app — a list of rules, click an item to read the rule — is similar to Constitution for iPhone, an app that I recently reviewed.  I prefer the fonts and graphical layout of Constitution for iPhone, although the design of FRCP is certainly functional.  Also, Constitution for iPhone includes notes on each article whereas FRCP does not include any commentary with the text of the rules, although that omission is largely irrelevant as you won’t be using your iPhone for in-depth procedural research; you will just use it to quickly find the text of a rule.  For only $2, the app is well worth it and is a useful tool on the iPhone of any litigator.

Click this button FRCP to download FRCP from the iTunes app store for $1.99.  [UPDATE 12/29/08:  The app was updated to add more features, such as admiralty and maritime rules, and the price is now $2.99.]

Using the exact same design as FRCP, Cliff Maier developed the following apps:

  • Bankruptcy
    Bankruptcy
    gives you Title 11 of the U.S. Code. $2.99.
  • FDCA
    FDCA
    gives you the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act as codified in Title 21 of the U.S. Code.  $3.99.
  • FRAP
    FRAP
    gives you the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure.  $1.99.
  • FRCrimPro
    FRCrimPro
    gives you the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.  $1.99.
  • FRE
    FRE
    gives you the Federal Rules of Evidence.  $1.99.
  • Lanham
    Lanham
    contains the Lanham Act, the portion of 15 U.S.C. that defines federal trademark law.  $1.99.
  • Patent Rules
    Patent Rules
    contains the local patent rules from five federal district courts (N.D. Cal., S.D. Cal., N.D. Ga., W.D. Pa. and E.D. Tex.)  $1.99.
  • Sarbanes Oxley
    Sarbanes Oxley
    gives you Title 15, Chapter 98 of the U.S. Code.  $1.99
  • Securities
    Securities
    gives you Sarbanes Oxley plus the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Investment Company Act of 1940 and the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.  $4.99.
  • Title 17
    Title 17
    gives you the federal copyright code.  $1.99.
  • Title 35
    Title 35
    gives you the federal patent laws.  $1.99.

Cliff Maier also has a version of the Constitution for $0.99.  As noted above, I prefer the design of Constitution for iPhone, which also has the advantage of being free.  But Cliff Maier’s version lets you search the full text, and for that feature alone you might want to pay the dollar and keep both versions on your iPhone. Constitution

Also, if you are a California lawyer, Cliff Maier has versions of the California Evidence Code ($1.99) CEC and the local patent rules for the N.D. Cal. ($0.99) Patent Local Rules (N.D. Cal. 2008)

10,000 and 300 million


Apple ran a full page ad on the back-page of the business section of the Friday, December 5, 2008 New York Times.  The ad is called “Solving life’s dilemmas one app at a time” and it gives examples of helpful apps.  But what I find most interesting is the announcement at the bottom that there are now 10,000 apps on the App Store — recall that there were only around 500 when the store launched just five months ago — and that iPhone users have already downloaded over 300 million apps.  Wow.

The 200 millionth app was downloaded on October 22, 2008, so it only took about six weeks to “sell” (many apps are free) the last 100 million.  That’s about 2 million apps downloaded every day, and the momentum is gaining.  Scott Kleinberg at the iPhone, Therefore, I Blog site predicts that at
this rate, there will be one billion downloads by some point in 2009.

Assuming that 20 million iPhones have been sold to date (just a wild guess by me that is probably a little high; Apple sold about 13 million iPhones as of the end of September of 2008) that means that the average iPhone user has downloaded 15 apps.

As they should.  There are so many well-designed, useful, inexpensive (and often free) apps available.  And with so many iPhones out there, software developers have a lot of incentive to make even better apps.

Here is the ad as it ran yesterday in the New York Times.  I understand that it also ran in the Wall Street Journal.  Sorry that the scan is just so-so; it is impossible to scan a full page of the NYT on my scanner so I let Photoshop try to stitch together partial scans.  Click to enlarge.


Review: Apple iPhone 3G Dock

The Apple iPhone 3G Dock is a $30 dock sold by Apple.  I use it at my office every day, throughout the day, and there is a lot to love about this simple little dock.  First, it gives me a specific place to keep my iPhone when I am working at my desk so that it is always in that same convenient location when I need to reach for it.  Second, it keeps my iPhone charged while it is sitting in the dock.  You can connect the dock to your computer to charge and sync, but I don’t actually use that feature because I don’t sync my iPhone with my work computer; I sync with my home iMac where I keep my music, photos and videos.  To send a charge to the dock, I connect an iPhone connector cord from the back of the dock to a USB power plug.  The dock does not come with a connector cord or a power plug, so you’ll either need to use the ones that came with your iPhone or buy an extra dock connector cable for $20 and an extra USB power adapter for $30 if you want to buy from Apple.  (Amazon sells some cheaper alternatives.)  I also found that the cable was not long enough to reach a power supply on the floor next to my desk, so I added a USB extension cable which you can buy at places like Amazon for just a few dollars.

Third, I like the dock because it keeps my iPhone upright and visible.  A quick tap on one of the iPhone’s buttons shows you the time, date and a battery indicator showing how charged it is.  Or you can keep the iPhone turned on and display a photograph (a single one or a slideshow), an iPhone app, or whatever else you want.  Note that your iPhone will auto-lock after a short amount of time unless you turn that feature off in Settings –> General –> Auto-Lock.  The dock itself is weighted just the right amount so that it will not fall over when your iPhone is in it, and rubber on the bottom gives you good traction so that it does not slip on your desk.

If you want to be more creative, there are lots of sites with tips for other ways to create a dock for your iPhone.  For example, click here for a YouTube video showing you how to turn a simple paper clip into a stand for your iPhone, and there is even a PDF file you can download so that you know exactly where to bend the paperclip to make the stand.  This sounds like a joke, but I tried it and it actually works quite well.  While the Apple iPhone 3G Dock keeps my iPhone in a portrait position, I sometimes put my iPhone on the paperclip stand to put the iPhone in a landscape position to display a video or just show a slideshow of pictures on my iPhone (the vast majority of which are wider than they are tall so landscape mode works better).

Going from the strangely useful to the increasingly absurd, this site shows you how to make an iPhone dock out of cardboard, and this video shows you how to create an iPhone stand out of a $100 bill.  I suppose you could do the same thing with a $1 bill to show your clients your frugality.  Ahem.

There are also some other companies that sell iPhone docks that might work for you on your desk.  Amazon sells quite a few of them and they differ from the Apple dock in different ways:  some are cheaper, some come with a connector cable, some add extra features such as a media card reader.  One interesting choice is the Griffin Powerdock Dual-Position Charging Station for iPod and iPhone
which lets you charge two iPhones (or an iPhone and an iPod) at the same time.  Another interesting choice is the PED3 Rotating Dock Stand that makes your iPhone look like a little computer monitor:

But back to the Apple dock, it is simple, sleek and works very well and I can recommend it.  It is somewhat overpriced, especially considering that it doesn’t come with a dock connector cable or a USB power plug, but it works well.  If you use it every day like I do, it is worth it.  Here are a few pictures, and you can click to view larger versions:

 

SnapTell Explorer and Amazon Mobile


Lawyers read all day long as a part of our jobs, and yet many of us also love to read during our increasingly rare free time.  Sometimes we see a book and think “hmm, I might want to read that one day.”  Of course, a few days later, you often forget about it.

There are now two free iPhone apps that perform a neat trick.  You can take a picture of a book using your iPhone, and then the app will figure out what the book is and give you information on the book, including links to buy it.

The first such app is called SnapTell Explorer.  It is very easy to use.  You start the app, take a picture of a book (or a CD, DVD or a video game), and then click one button to use your picture.  The app sends the picture off to a server, and within seconds it identifies the book and gives you links to buy the book various places on the web, look up info on the book on Wikipedia, etc.  And even after you quit the app, it saves your prior entries.  Thus, you can snap a picture of a book when you see it, and then a few days later start the app and you’ll think “oh yeah, I wanted to remind myself to get that book” and you will have the resources at your fingertips to do so.

 

 

Another app that does a similar trick is the free Amazon Mobile app.  The primary function of the app is to be a great Amazon client on the iPhone.  Search for items on Amazon, read reviews, purchase items, check the status of your previous orders, etc.  Although this app is new, those functions are not; Amazon has long had a great version of its website formatted for the iPhone.  Just access the normal Amazon website on your iPhone at www.amazon.com and the Amazon website will sense that you are using Safari on an iPhone and automatically show you a full-featured version of the website that looks great on your screen.  But the new feature added by the Amazon Mobile app is a feature called “Amazon Remembers.”  Just like SnapTell Explorer, you take a picture of a book (or any other item) with the iPhone.  But instead of a computer analyzing the picture to determine what the book is, a real person will look at the picture, try to figure out what it is, and then send information to your Amazon Mobile app (and send you an e-mail) so that you can view the item on Amazon, read reviews, and if you want, buy it.  (It appears that Amazon is using people who participate in its Mechanical Turk program do the work; Amazon reportedly pays them 10 cents for each one they do.)  Amazon says it can take up to two days for an item to be analyzed, but in my tests it took only about a minute — longer than SnapTell Explorer, but still very fast.


 

On both SnapTell Explorer and Amazon Mobile, the feature doesn’t always work.  Indeed, Amazon explicitly warns that the Amazon Remembers feature is still experimental.  But most of the time it works well, and frankly the fact that it works at all seems like magic, especially on SnapTell Explorer when you consider that a computer is successfully deciphering a book cover in just a few seconds.  Apparently, you can tell a lot about a book from its cover.

Click this button SnapTell Explorer to download SnapTell Explorer for free from iTunes.

Click this button Amazon Mobile to download Amazon Mobile for free from iTunes.

Alltop


For the first year that the original iPhone was around, Apple did not let other companies make applications for the iPhone — something hard to imagine now that there are approximately 10,000 apps available in iTunes.  (Click here for icons of all of them on a single page put together by the site 148apps.com, and click here for a fun mosaic image of an iPhone made up of apps icons created by the folks at TapTapTap.com.  By the way, the name “148 apps” refers to the fact that the iPhone can hold 9 pages of apps, 16 icons a page, plus 4 more at the bottom, which is a total of 148 apps.)  But during that first year of the iPhone, where there were no apps, Apple encouraged others to instead make web pages specially formatted for the iPhone to add additional functionality to the iPhone.

Even today, some of the most-used icons on my iPhone’s Home Screen are not apps but instead are links to web pages specially formatted for the iPhone.  (When you are on a web page in Safari, tape the plus icon at the bottom to create a bookmark, then click the button that says “Add to Home Screen,” and then there will be an icon on your Home Screen that looks just like an application icon but that links to the web page.)  One such website with a great iPhone interface is Alltop.

You can access Alltop from your computer at http://alltop.com.  It is a great website started by three people, one of whom is Guy Kawasaki, one of the original Apple employees who became famous for being the chief evangelist for the company in the 1980s and then again in the 1990s.  When you go to Alltop, you select one of hundreds of topics such as Agriculture, Extreme Sports, Kids, Macintosh, Photography, Wine or Zoology.  Alltop then shows you what it considers to be the top blogs devoted to the subject and the last few posts from each of those blogs, all on a single, easy to skim page.  One of the largest pages is the Alltop page for Law which lists over 150 great law blogs.  Just to pick one example:  SCOTUSblog is the best source for U.S. Supreme Court news, with everything that you need to know on cases being considered, live blogging the second that new opinions are released, etc.  If you are following a case before the Supreme Court, you need to read SCOTUSblog.  By just skimming the Law page, you get a survey of the top legal stories being discussed by all of the top law blogs, including SCOTUSblog, and you can click on links to jump to specific blogs and read more.

Alltop looks great on a web browser on your computer, and the mobile version of Alltop looks fantastic on an iPhone screen.  I encourage you to keep on your iPhone a bookmark to either the main Alltop mobile page, http://alltop.com/m/, or a link to the specific Alltop page that is of particular interest to you.  The Law one, for example, is http://law.alltop.com/m/.  The next time you have a few minutes of downtime, such as standing in line at the grocery, you can look at Alltop on your iPhone and instantly get up-to-date on law or whatever other topic strikes your fancy.

Those of you who currently use an RSS reader might be wondering, isn’t Alltop the same thing?  In a way it is because Alltop relies on RSS feeds.  But the great thing about Alltop is that they have already done the work and found the best sites for you.  If you wake up one morning and find yourself interested in reading about bacon, the Alltop Bacon page has already picked out the top 17 sources of Bacon news.  That’s right, 17 sites on bacon.  I kid you not.

I had long ago planned to write about Alltop on iPhone J.D. because I use it all the time to scan the top blogs that cover Law, Macintosh and the iPhone.  But just a few days ago I was honored to learn that Alltop has added iPhone J.D. to its iPhone page.  As the most recent addition, it is all the way at the bottom of the Alltop iPhone page, but we all have to start somewhere!

So add a bookmark to Alltop to your iPhone.  Alltop is efficient, effective, and best of all, free.  Free as in Beer.

   

Review: Wikipanion – Wikipedia for iPhone


An important part of being a lawyer is accessing information, assessing its credibility, and then using it to your client’s advantage.  Wikipedia is a fantastic source of information.  You need to always be careful to assess credibility because just about anyone can add anything to a Wikipedia entry, but in my experience Wikipedia has been a great way to quickly learn about a topic.

You can access the Wikipedia web pages on your iPhone in Safari, but the text can be a little small.  Thus, there are a number of iPhone apps that aim to make it easier to access Wikipedia.  My favorite has always been Wikipanion, an app that doesn’t deserve placement on my iPhone’s first home screen but does go on the top of the second page. 

For example, in my November 26, 2008 entry on iPhone J.D., I mentioned the right to privacy and I wanted to give a quick link to something discussing the fact that the right is not explicitly referenced in the U.S. Constitution.  So I fired up Wikipanion and typed “Right to Privacy” at the search bar at the top.  At the top of the screen, Wikipanion will show you any articles that have a title relating to your search terms, or you can tap “Full Wikipedia Search” to look for that phrase in an article.  That brought me to a screen with a bunch of possible hits, and the eighth one down is Griswold v. Connecticut.  Tap once on that entry, and you can see the full Wikipedia entry on the landmark Griswold case, formatted nicely for the iPhone screen.

 

 

The excellent site iLounge recently reviewed 16 different iPhone apps that give you access to Wikipedia, and Wikipanion is also their favorite.  In fact, they give it an “A” rating, and that is really saying something because iLounge is not known for being generous with their grades; lots of apps and accessories that I love only get a B+ or A- from iLounge.  If you are interested in accessing Wikipedia on your iPhone, you should definitely take a look at the iLounge article.  Also, the Wikipanion website has lots of great information about Wikipanion and its $5 big brother, Wikipanion Plus (which adds more features such as the ability to download a Wikipedia page so that you can access it later even when you are not connected to the Internet).

Click this button Wikipanion to download Wikipanion for free from iTunes.

Upgrading your iPhone


Attorney Kevin Camden from Woodbridge, Illinois writes in with this question:  Is it possible to upgrade from the first generation iPhone to the current iPhone 3G, and if so, what do you have to do and what is the cost?  Thanks for the question, Kevin, and if anyone else has a question that I can try to answer on iPhone J.D., please e-mail me at jeff@iphonejd.com.

From a software standpoint, there is essentially no difference between any of the iPhones.  Whether you have the first model released in 2007 or the latest iPhone 3G, you can (and should) upgrade for free to the current version 2.2 of the iPhone operating system.  The upgrade should happen automatically when you sync with iTunes on your computer.  I mention this because I have heard some lawyers say that they don’t sync their iPhones because they don’t add music, photos or videos, but syncing is important to backup the contents of your iPhone and to keep the operating system up to date.

From a hardware standpoint, you cannot upgrade the first generation iPhone to the iPhone 3G to add the new features such as the faster 3G radio, GPS and increased memory.  You can, however, buy a new iPhone 3G even if you still have time left on your AT&T contract for your original iPhone.  When you buy the new iPhone, you will simply start a new two year contract.  The cost is the normal $200 for an 8GB model and $300 for the 16GB model.

But what do you do with your used, original iPhone?  One option is to share the love and give it to a friend.  The happy recipient can go to an AT&T store, have it assigned to their account, and start using it.  Another option is to sell the old iPhone and, if you do so, you might get $200-$300, more than enough money to pay for the iPhone 3G.

How is it possible to get more money for an older model iPhone than it costs to get the new iPhone 3G?  There are a couple of reasons for that, including that a new 8GB iPhone doesn’t really cost $200.  The actual cost is probably closer to $500 because analysts believe that AT&T subsidizes about $300 of the cost and makes up that money over the length of your AT&T contract.  Also, used iPhones are still valuable because they can be unlocked so that they work with phone carriers in other countries and thus many companies buy used iPhones in the U.S. and sell them overseas.  You can sell your iPhone on eBay or Craigslist, and a quick look at completed auctions on eBay shows that over the last several weeks, lots of the first generation iPhones (4GB and 8GB) were purchased for $200 to almost $400 (with unopened and like-new iPhones fetching the highest prices).  Another option is to use a website that specializes in buying used iPhones.  I haven’t tried and thus cannot vouch for any of these, but examples that I found on a quick Google search include:

These sites say that they will pay you between $100 and $300 for a used iPhone, depending upon the model and the condition it is in.

So now that you know what you can do with your old iPhone, if you have one of the first generation iPhones, should you buy a new iPhone 3G?  The answer depends on your needs.  3G is much better than Edge, but you need to think about how much time you spend in an area with a WiFi connection, where that doesn’t matter.  The GPS is nice when you need it and I use it at least once a week, but it is just a nice bonus, not an essential feature, and perhaps you already have a GPS.  If you have an original 4GB iPhone, are you frequently running out of space to add new apps, new music, etc. such that the 8GB or 16GB models would give you welcome breathing room?

Finally, if you are going to buy a new iPhone, should you buy one now or wait?  Only Apple (and perhaps AT&T) knows when the next iPhone will come out.  For the past two years, new iPhones have been released in the middle of the Summer, so perhaps the next model will come out in June or July of 2009 and you won’t feel buyer’s remorse if you upgrade today.  But also remember that every year in early January, Apple CEO Steve Jobs gives a keynote presentation at the huge Macworld Conference in San Francisco.  The next one is scheduled for January 6 to January 9, 2009 and we can be sure that Steve Jobs will announce something new — we just don’t know whether it will be a new model of the iPhone or something else like a new Macintosh computer.  The website MacRumors maintains a Buyer’s Guide where they try to predict whether the time is right to buy a new Mac, iPod or iPhone.  Their current advice for an iPhone is “Don’t Buy – Updates Soon” and their explanation is offered here.

Kevin, hopefully this answers your question, and perhaps it gives those who bought an iPhone before July 11, 2008 something to think about.

Give the gift of iPhone

Thanksgiving is over and Black Friday is upon us, so it is time to starting thinking about the prefect present for the lawyer in your life –perhaps even yourself.  Attorney Reid Trautz runs the Reid My Blog! website and recently unveiled the 2008 edition of his annual Holiday Gift Guide for Lawyers.  There are lots of fun ideas in here if you are looking to go beyond the standard gifts like a tie, but what caught my attention is that, for the second year in a row, the iPhone makes the list.  He explains:

Faithful readers will recognize the iPhone is a repeat in The Guide this year. Thanks to my dear wife who read the 2007 Guide, I received my iPhone for Christmas and have never looked back. This terrific tech tool may seem like a toy because it is so fun to use, but it is built for serious business. With Outlook Exchange integration and a growing plethora of useful web applications, this is the smartphone to have, hands down!

[UPDATE 12/15/08:  The website Patent Baristas also has a list of “Best Gifts for Patent Attorneys” with the iPhone at the top of its list.]

I can’t agree more.  The original version of the iPhone would not have made my 2007 list for any lawyer in a Microsoft Exchange environment, but the 2.0 software and 3G version of the iPhone released earlier this year make the iPhone an easy pick for the lawyer in your life, especially if he or she likes gadgets.

Until recently, it was hard to give an iPhone 3G as a gift.  You can’t buy an actual iPhone without setting up service, transferring the phone number from the prior phone, etc. which eliminates the element of surprise.  But Apple just fixed that problem by releasing the new iPhone 3G Gift Card.  You can buy it either online or in a retail Apple Store, and the amount can be for anything from $25 to $2,500.  Umm, $2,500?  Well you see, it is just a normal gift card that can be used for anything at the Apple Store, but when you put $200 or $300 on it, your lucky recipient can afford an 8GB or 16GB phone.  (I have the 16GB model myself, but unless you have a ton of music and video that you want to keep on the iPhone, the 8GB is perfect for most lawyers’ needs — unless you really want the white model, which only comes in 16GB.)

And if the lawyer in your life already has an iPhone?  Give them an iTunes gift card to let them fill it up with apps, music and videos.

Happy Holidays!

Is the Blackberry Storm a turkey? [updated]


There are a lot of companies out there trying to come out with a smartphone that is better than the iPhone, and it would seem that if anyone can do it, it is R.I.M. with its impressive Blackberry.  E-mail on a Blackberry with a physical keyboard is great, and in my opinion currently a little better than the iPhone, although Apple adds new features to the iPhone every few months and is surely working on improving e-mail. 

R.I.M.’s answer to the iPhone is the Blackberry Storm, the first Blackberry with a large touchscreen and no keyboard. I haven’t had a chance to try one yet myself, but [UPDATE: see below.]  David Pogue, the personal technology columnist for the New York Times, thinks that it is a turkey — and not the delicious kind that those of us in the U.S. are enjoying today.  His review is an entertaining read, as long as you don’t work for R.I.M.  For example:

In short, trying to navigate this thing isn’t just an exercise in frustration — it’s a marathon of frustration.  I haven’t found a soul who tried this machine who wasn’t appalled, baffled or both.  And that’s before they discovered that the Storm doesn’t have Wi-Fi. … How did this thing ever reach the market?  Was everyone involved just too terrified to pull the emergency brake on this train?

The folks over at the grand-daddy of all gadget sites, Engadget, were similarly unimpressed in their extensive review:

[I]t’s not as easy, enjoyable, or consistent to use as the iPhone, and the one place where everyone is sure they have an upper hand — that wow-inducing clickable screen — just isn’t all that great. For casual users, the learning curve and complexity of this phone will feel like an instant turn off, and for power users, the lack of a decent typing option and considerable lagginess in software will give them pause. RIM tried to strike some middle ground between form and function, and unfortunately came up short on both.

I am glad that R.I.M. is trying to innovate and take on the iPhone.  The competition can only serve to make all smartphones better.  And it seems that another, more traditional, Blackberry model, the Blackberry Bold, has a lot to offer any lawyer who is only interested in e-mail and who feels that a physical keyboard is necessary.  But given these initial reviews, the Blackberry Storm doesn’t appear to measure up to the iPhone.

UPDATE 11/27/08:  I had the chance to try out a Blackberry Storm just a few hours after I published the above post, and I have to say that I agree with the above two reviews.  The main thing that I wanted to try was e-mail because that is where a Blackberry should excel.  But typing on a Storm is a disaster.  When your finger touches a key, the key lights up and you think that you have typed the letter, but no — you need to also click down to type.  Well then what is the point of lighting up the key?  And pressing down on the screen to click feels both unnatural and unpleasant, like a button on a very cheap plastic mouse.  It also slows down typing substantially.  Unlike the iPhone where scrolling is very fluid, scrolling on the Storm is jerky.  Beyond e-mail, I tried out the web browser and some of the other applications, and all of them seem to require a few more taps and clicks that seems necessary.  Can a user get used to the quirks over time?  Perhaps, but the Storm stands in sharp contrast to the iPhone, which is intuitive and natural to use from the outset.  My advice for those lawyers who don’t want to or for some reason can’t use an iPhone is to get a more traditional Blackberry with a physical keyboard.

UPDATE 12/4/08:  Click here for an interesting follow up to David Pogue’s New York Times review of the Blackberry Storm.

Review: Constitution – the Constitution in your pocket

Justice Hugo Black, known for his literal reading of the U.S. Constitution, used to always keep a well-worn copy in his pocket so that he could take it out and quote from it.  He served on the Supreme Court from 1937 until he died in 1971, so he missed even the early days of the personal computer revolution.  But were he alive today, perhaps he would trade in his paper copy for an iPhone loaded with the Constitution, a free application from Clint Bagwell Consulting

All of your favorites are here.  You can sing along to “We the people … in order to form a more perfect union” and wonder why the Schoolhouse Rock version of the Preamble omits the phrase “of the United States.”  You can read the Bill of Rights and the Fourteenth Amendment, which are truly as timely today as they were in 1789 and 1868.  You can read the Eighteenth Amendment’s prohibition of intoxicating liquors and then toast the Twenty-First Amendment’s repeal of prohibition. 

This application is simple, and frankly that is a good thing.  The main page is just a table of contents and you tap to read the full text of a section.  And each section includes notes including, for example, the dates of ratification of each of the amendments.  The application is quick and easy to use.

At the risk of fueling the debate over whether the right to privacy is in there, I do wish that the application had a search function, but otherwise this application is great.  It is free, it takes up virtually no space on your iPhone, and if you are a lawyer — or, for that matter, just a good citizen — you really have no excuse not to download it.

Click this button app to download Constitution for iPhone and iPod Touch from the iTunes Store.

   

And finally, because I couldn’t resist, the Schoolhouse Rock video for the Preamble: