Apple has been making a box called the Apple TV since 2007. Other companies make cheaper devices that can connect to a TV and stream video, but as each new Apple TV model has come out, it has always been a high-quality device that works extremely well with other Apple devices. Thus, if you already use an iPhone, iPad, and/or Mac, I've always thought that it was worth the extra money to get an Apple TV instead of devices sold by other companies. On April 20, 2021, Apple introduced the latest version of the Apple TV called the Apple TV 4K (2nd generation). I've been using one for the last few weeks, and for me it was an upgrade from an Apple TV HD, which I reviewed in 2015 (at a time when it was called the Apple TV fourth generation). I'm very happy with the new features of this version of the Apple TV, and I recommend it — even if you, like me, don't have a 4K television.
What I continue to love
Just in case you don't yet have an Apple TV, let me begin by making a pitch for this device. The Apple TV is great for streaming video and works with all of the major video streaming services like Netflix. It also works seamlessly with the iCloud Photo Library, so all of the pictures on my iPhone, iPad, and Mac are also available on the Apple TV, which is a great way to show off pictures and videos to friends and family. I also use it to stream all of the video files that are on my Mac, which is on the same network at my home.
The Apple TV has an App Store, so you can download apps such as games. I don't use apps nearly as much as I use the Apple TV to stream video or photos, but I use them sometimes.
Consistent with Apple's commitment to privacy, the Apple TV doesn't spy on what you are watching and sell your habits to third parties. Note that your TV itself may still try to do so when it is connected to an Apple TV, but the Apple TV doesn't play any role in that.
An Apple TV works as an AirPlay speaker so it can play audio at the same time as other devices. For example, in my house, I have two HomePod minis and an Apple TV in different rooms on the first floor of my house. I can tell music to play simultaneously on all three devices so that the same music plays in all of the rooms.
An Apple TV can also act as a hub for your HomeKit accessories so that you can control them or check their status even if you are not in the house. For example, you can turn on the porch light before you get home.
And finally, it is incredibly easy to share the screen of an iPhone or iPad to an Apple TV. This is really nice if friends or family come over and want to share pictures from their iPhone so that we can all see them on the big screen. There are now some TVs that you can buy with built-in AirPlay functionality, but an Apple TV makes this great feature work with any TV.
The new remote
Depending upon how you count them, the new Apple TV comes with either the fourth or fifth version of an Apple TV remote. The original remote in 2007 was very small and white. In 2010, Apple introduced a thin silver model that was easier to hold. In 2015, Apple introduced the black Apple TV remote. There were some nice feature to that remote, but also had some drawbacks: the symmetrical design and flat buttons made it difficult to figure out which button you were pressing in a dark room, and worse, yet, made it hard to know if the remote was upside down in your hand. I'm honestly surprised that Apple kept that remote around for six years. Apple made one small change to the Apple remote during that time, placing a white circle around the MENU button, but that was about the smallest change that one could make to the remote to make it easier to use, so I don't really consider that a different remote model.
With this year's update to the Apple TV, we now have a new silver remote. It is thicker than previous models, which is a good thing because it makes it easier to hold in your hands. It also makes it harder for the remote to slip between cushions on your couch.
The new remote also features a touchpad, but it is part of a four-directional D-pad. Thus, if you want to use it as a touchpad you can, but if it is easier to just click buttons to go up/down/left/right, you can do that instead. I find that it is easier to jump 10 seconds forwards/backwards in a video by pressing the right/left D-pad arrows than it ever was to do the same thing with the old remote.
Better yet, because the D-pad is in a circular shape, you can use it as a jog dial — spin your finger around the circle to scrub through a video. That feature only works in Apple TV apps that are made to work with the feature, but I presume that most services will add this feature. To use that feature, pick up your finger from the D-pad and then place your finger along the edge of the circle for about a second or two. You will see a circle appear on screen around your current position in the video, and then you can move your finger around the circle as much as you need to get to a new position in the video, either forward or backward.
The circular D-pad is also nice because it provides an obvious physical barrier to the touch surface. With the old remote, it was easy to accidentally touch the touch pad when picking up the remote. That is far less likely with the new remote.
The new remote also moves some buttons around and adds new buttons. The Siri button is moved from the face of the remote to the side edge, which reduces the chance that you will trigger Siri accidentally. I find that it also makes Siri easier to trigger in the first place because I don't have to look down at the remote to find the Siri button before I can press it. There is also a new power button at the top right. It turns the Apple TV itself on or off, and also turns on/off other devices that support HDMI-CEC. For me, the power button will turn on (or off) both my Apple TV and my TV, but not my audio receiver. Finally, there is a new mute button, which is something that I always missed on the prior remote.
Like prior models, the volume up/down buttons can either control the sound via HDMI, or you can teach them to use RF to work with an audio source. Thus, I can use the remote to control the volume on my audio receiver.
Like before, the circle button at the top right is the Apple TV+ button. Press it to jump directly to the Apple TV+ app. If you prefer, in Settings you can reprogram that button to go to the home screen. If you keep that as an Apple TV+ button, you can always hold down the back button for a few seconds to jump directly to the home screen. And if you hold down the top right Apple TV+ button for a few seconds, you can see the Control Center — a quick way to connect to AirPods, see the time, and perform some other functions.
The new remote is such an improvement over the prior model that Apple is selling it separately for $59 so that you can use it with any of the Apple TV models that came with the black remote. And if you already have the first generation Apple TV 4K, you may not need or want the new features in this second generation Apple TV 4K other than the remote. However, if you are currently using the Apple TV HD that was released in 2015, consider instead upgrading the new Apple TV 4K like I did. If you have an even older model of the Apple TV, then I have an even stronger recommendation that you upgrade. (Click here to see a page on the Apple website that you can use to identify which Apple TV model you have.)
The new Apple TV 4K
Here are the other features of the new Apple TV 4K that make it a worthy upgrade from a prior model, and make it a great device if this is your first Apple TV.
4K. I don't have a 4K television. I bought the last model of the Panasonic VIERA plasma TV before Panasonic and the rest of the industry stopped making plasma televisions. This type of plasma TV looks great if you are in a room that doesn't have windows, so I'm not in a rush to give it up, but at some point in the future I'm sure I will upgrade to a 4K TV with HDR. If you have a 4K television, especially one that supports HDR, then the reviews I have read indicate that you can make the most of your TV with this newest Apple TV because of the HDR support.
One note about HDR. Although I don't have a TV that supports HDR, I know that it looks great on the latest models of the iPad Pro and the iPhone, so whenever I record video on my iPhone, I record it using 4K at 60 fps using Dolby Vision. This results in videos that look incredibly true to life. With my Apple TV HD, I often had trouble playing these videos on my TV, especially if I modified the videos using Final Cut Pro. I knew that I would not see the full spectrum of dark to light areas because my TV doesn't support Dolby Vision HDR, but I still wanted to see the video on my TV. This new Apple TV 4K will display all of those videos on my TV. No, I don't get the full effect of HDR like I do on my iPad, but this new Apple TV can still produce a nice version of the video that works on my TV.
This is important to me because the main reason I shoot in 4K HDR today is so that my home videos will look as good as possible 5, 10, 15, etc. years from now. When my kids were young, I bought a HD camcorder that recorded to tapes, and I'm glad that I did so because those videos still look very good today, whereas the home videos I took before that using a camcorder look pretty pitiful.
Speed. Unsurprisingly, this new model is much faster than the 2015 model that I had been using. It is faster in multiple ways.
First, the Apple TV HD and earlier models only supported 100 Mb/sec Ethernet. Like the first generation Apple TV 4K, this second generation model supports Gigabit Ethernet, which is 10x faster. I use the eero Pro to provide Wi-Fi in my house, and the eero Pro in my TV room has a wired Gigabit Ethernet connection to my router. I use the second Ethernet port on my eero Pro to connect to my new Apple TV, and it makes a huge and noticeable difference on downloads. When I stream video, it plays virtually instantly. With my prior Apple TV, the Speed Test app never showed speeds about 100, whereas with this new Apple TV, I get scores above 900.
Second, the new Apple TV 4K has a faster chip in it. This is probably another reason that the Photos app works so much better. This new model uses an A12, the same chip that was first used on the iPhone XS, XS Max, and XR in 2018. (The Apple TV HD uses an A8 chip, which was first used on iPhone 6 in 2014.) With this much faster chip, everything has much more zip to it. It is a noticeable and very welcome improvement.
These two changes — the faster Internet and the faster chip — result in a vastly improved experience when I use the Photos app on the Apple TV, which downloads pictures from my iCloud Photo Library. Still photos now display almost instantly, whereas with my older Apple TV, I had to wait a while for them to appear. Live Photos — the ones you take with your iPhone that have a short video associated with them — sometimes appear almost instantly, and sometimes take about a second to load, but again, that is far better than what I used to see.
A third reason that this new Apple TV is faster is, if you use Wi-Fi 6, the newest version of Wi-Fi, this is the first Apple TV model to support it. But note that if you use a wired Ethernet connection like I do, then the Internet speed will be the same on this second generation Apple TV 4K as it was on the first generation Apple TV 4K.
Other technical improvements. Finally, this new version of the Apple TV supports the latest-and-greatest standards for video, audio, and connectivity. Things like HDR10, Dolby Vision, Bluetooth 5, HDMI 2.1, 2160p, Dolby Atmos, Thread, etc. You know, all the new and fancy buzz words. To take advantage of these features, you need to make sure these features are supported by other devices that you use to watch TV, such as the TV itself and your receiver if you use one.
I use an older audio receiver that supports 5.1 surround sound and Dolby Digital but not Dolby Atmos. When I first started using this new Apple TV, I noticed that when I watched programs that use Dolby Atmos, such as shows on Apple TV+, I would only hear the left and right speakers, but not the center or rear speakers. To solve this, in the Settings app on the Apple TV, I told the Apple TV to always use 5.1 sound. With that one change, everything works for me.
I noticed a connectivity improvement when using Apple's Fitness+ app to do a workout. On my prior Apple TV, when I was using both my Apple Watch and my AirPods Pro (so that others in the house didn't need to listen to my workout), my watch or AirPods Pro would sometimes lose their connection with the Apple TV. That is not what you want to happen in the middle of a workout. That hasn't happened at all with this new Apple TV. I don't know why this is fixed: perhaps it is the Bluetooth 5 support, perhaps it is the faster processor, or perhaps it is something else. But it's nice to not have to worry about this anymore.
Storage. You can purchase an Apple TV with either 32GB or 64GB of storage. For virtually anyone, either size should be sufficient for whatever apps you want to download. Because the price difference is only $20, I opted for the larger size because I've seen some reports that the Apple TV can take advantage of the extra space to store photos and videos in the cache, meaning that they come up more quickly if you go to look at them again. I don't think that I've ever seen Apple confirm that the extra storage space is used this way, but hopefully that is true. Speaking of price, the official MSRP is $179 (32GB) or $199 (64GB), but I see that Amazon is currently selling both models with a $10 discount.
Conclusion
Apple doesn't update the Apple TV very often, sometimes going two years, three years, or more between updates. Thus, on the somewhat rare occasions when a new Apple TV model is introduced, that is a good time to consider upgrading from an older model. Since I never used the first generation Apple TV 4K released in 2017, I don't have any first-hand experience to recommend whether this is enough of an improvement to recommend an upgrade from that specific model. Here's some advice from Chris Welch of The Verge:
If you have the original Apple TV 4K, there’s really no sensible reason to upgrade to the new one. Wi-Fi 6 is nice to have, and Thread might prove important to the smart home someday, but that time isn’t now. Otherwise, you’re getting a slightly faster experience than what the old box is capable of. Just buy the Siri Remote, and call it a day.
But if you have the Apple TV HD (originally called the Apple TV fourth generation) that was released in 2015 or an earlier model, then I think that this is an excellent time to upgrade to take advantage of all of the improvements. And if you have never used an Apple TV before, this is a great time to get one.
Click here to get Apple TV 4K (second generation) from Amazon ($169 / $189).