Just over two years ago, I posted a review of the original version of Apple's AirPods. My review was glowing because they instantly made the list of my all-time favorite products from Apple. They feel like they weigh nothing in your ears and they don't fall out, they let you avoid the numerous frustrations associated with having a cord run from your ears to your iPhone, and the convenient charging case gives you an easy place to store them which also keeps them charged.
I also like being able to double-tap on each AirPod to trigger a gesture. In my original review, I noted having problems getting this gesture to work reliably, but Apple solved that with a software update. In September 2017, Apple released iOS 11, adding the ability to assign a different gesture for each AirPod. (For me, I'd tap my left AirPod to trigger Siri and my right AirPod to play/pause.)
I used my AirPods every single day, sometimes for hours each day, since early 2017. As I started to near two years of use, I noticed that the battery in each AirPod wasn't lasting as long, especially in my right AirPod — which makes sense, because sometimes I would use just one AirPod instead of both of them, and I virtually always used the right AirPod when I was using just one. For listening to music or podcasts, my AirPods were only lasting about an hour, and for phone calls they would last about 20-30 minutes. Each AirPod is very small, which means that the rechargeable battery inside of each AirPod is tiny, and apparently after two years of recharging, the ability of each battery to hold a charge had decreased substantially. It was still fast and easy to charge the AirPods in the charging case, but having to do that much more often wasn't any fun.
Because the batteries were starting to wear out of this device that I use every day, I was in the market for a new pair of AirPods when Apple announced the second generation AirPods. I purchased the model with the normal Charging Case (not the Wireless Charging Case — more on that below.) I’ve been using them for almost a week now, and they work great.
Much is the same
In most ways, the second generation AirPods are the same as before. The AirPods and the charging case look the same. The only real difference is that after carrying the original charging case every day for over two years, it is more scratched up and the white color is no longer quite as bright as a new pair.
Engraving
Although the case looks the same as before, you now have the option to add custom laser engraving. This is especially nice when you have multiple people using AirPods in the same household because it can sometimes be confusing to tell which AirPods belong to which person. There is no charge for the engraving. You can fit around 15-20 characters depending upon the width of the characters you use. I had no trouble fitting “iPhone J.D.” on my Charging Case.
More call time
Because the batteries in my original AirPods were starting to wear out, I knew that any new AirPods were going to last much longer for me, even new first generation AirPods. But one unique advantage of the second generation AirPods is that Apple has improved battery life when you are on a call. The original AirPods could be used for up to five hours of listening between charges or two hours of a phone call. I have had quite a few long conferences calls when my AirPods started to run out of battery. (To address this, I would take out one AirPod and charge it for a few minutes, and then replace it and charge the other AirPod, using only one ear to participate in the conference call during those times.)
The second generation AirPods can go up to three hours for a phone call. I have no doubt that the 50% increase in talk time is going to be valuable to me when I am taking long calls out of the office on my iPhone.
Speaking of using the AirPods to talk on the phone, I see that Rene Ritchie of iMore has reported that the second generation AirPods improve microphone reception during windy weather. I haven’t had a chance to test that myself, but those of you in Chicago and other windy cities will appreciate that.
Switch between devices more quickly
Although I usually use my AirPods with my iPhone, I frequently switch them to another device, such as my iPad, my Apple Watch, or the iMac I use at home. Switching with the first generation AirPods would usually take 5 to 6 seconds. Switching between devices is twice as fast with the new AirPods. Saving 2-3 seconds doesn’t sound like a lot, but I notice it, and really appreciate it, every single time I switch devices. This is a small change, but I really like it.
Hey Siri — without tapping a button
Talking to Siri with AirPods has always been useful, such as when I want to send someone a text message or initiate a phone call without having to reach for my iPhone. Thus, I assigned a double-tap on my left AirPod to initiate Siri. But with the second generation AirPods, you can just say “Hey Siri” out loud followed by your instruction.
This makes it easier to use Siri because I don’t have to double-tap an AirPod first, but more importantly for me, it allows me to use the double-tap of my left AirPod to perform a different function. I now have it assigned to Next Track, which is useful when I using the Overcast app to listen to a podcast because the Next Track function will skip the podcast forward by 30 seconds, useful for skipping a commercial that I’ve already heard and don’t need to hear again. (In Overcast, you can adjust that to 7, 15, 30, 45, or 60 seconds.)
The hinge
This may sound silly if you have never used an AirPods Charging Case before, but there is something incredibly satisfying about opening and closing the case. It just feels and sounds right, so much so that sometimes when I am fidgeting, I find myself just opening and closing the case. And I know that I’m not alone in doing that.
I can’t see, feel, or hear any difference in the second generation Charging Case, but iFixIt took the new Charging Case apart and discovered: “This machined metal hinge looks sturdier compared to the last generation's, and it definitely has the adhesive to match.” iFixIt was reviewing the wireless version of the Charging Case so perhaps that accounts for the difference, but the hinge was such a nice feature of the first generation AirPods case that it would be great if Apple did find a way to make it more durable.
Wireless Charging Case
The second generation AirPods cost the same $159 as the prior model. However, for an additional $40, you can purchase AirPods with a Wireless Charging Case. Or you can purchase a Wireless Charging Case on its own for $79 to use them with your first generation AirPods.
I’ve now owned two iPhones that support wireless charging, and I’ve never found this feature to be all that important. I don’t find it that cumbersome to use a Lightning cord to charge an iPhone, and you can charge an iPhone much faster with a cord than with a wireless Qi charger. I understand why folks find them convenient, and I have used them from time to time, but it is just not a big deal to me.
Similarly, it has never been a problem for me to use a cord to charge an AirPods Charging Case, especially because they charge so quickly. Even though my first generation AirPods were having issues with the battery, my charging case was doing fine and continued to last a long time before needing to be recharged.
In 2016, Apple announced that it was coming out with its own wireless charger called AirPower which would be better than all of the other Qi chargers on the market because it could charge up to three devices at once (such as an iPhone, Apple Watch, and AirPods charging case). However, Apple announced last week that it is canceling that long-overdue product because Apple couldn’t get the engineering to work. If Apple had released the AirPower and I had purchased one, maybe I would have found a Wireless Charging Case to be more useful, but with Apple’s announcement, that will no longer be an issue for me.
If wireless charging matters to you, you may consider it worth the extra $40 when you are purchasing second generation AirPods, and I’m glad that this is now an option. It didn’t seem worth it to me, and so far I haven’t regretted that decision at all.
Conclusion
All of the improvements I described above are minor. But taken together, they make the already great AirPods even better. If you are already using first generation AirPods and they are not (yet) having battery problems, then I do not recommend that you upgrade. But if you are like me and you wore out your original AirPods, it is nice to have some new features when you get a new pair.
If you are not yet using AirPods, and if you ever use your iPhone or iPad to make sound to watch a video, listen to music, listen to podcasts, etc., then I think that you will love the AirPods. This is especially true if you own an Apple Watch because you can connect an Apple Watch to a pair of AirPods and then leave your iPhone and other devices at home, streaming music or podcasts directly from the watch to the AirPods.
Click here to get the second generation AirPods on Amazon ($159)