I recently reviewed the Adonit Jot Script, the first iPad stylus that had a fine point tip, which works because the stylus also emits a signal that makes an iPad sense something larger making contact with the screen. It is an amazing stylus, but it has some disadvantages such as being noisy and lacking a clip. However, the Jot Script is not the only powered stylus for the iPad. About a week ago, Cregle sent me a free review sample of the Cregle ink, another fine point stylus that uses a battery. It seems like the Cregle ink was specifically designed to address each of the shortcomings of the Adonit Jot Script — although the Cregle ink also lacks some of the advantages of the Jot Script.
Fine tip that is quiet
The main feature of a stylus like this is the fine tip, so I'll talk about that feature first. The Cregle ink has a very fine tip. It is not quite as small as the tip on the Adonit Jot Script — the Cregle ink tip is 2.4 mm; the Jot Script tip is 1.9 mm — but I didn't notice that size difference when using the styluses. Both tips are sufficiently small to feel like a pen tip, as opposed to a traditional stylus that has a size closer to a thick marker or a crayon.
The following picture shows the tip of the Jot Script, then the Cregle ink, then the Wacom Bamboo Stylus duo (which has a 5 mm tip that is smaller than the 6 mm tip you see on most other styluses).
The small size of the tip on the Cregle ink, like the tip on the Jot Script, provides a completely different sensation when writing on an iPad. I raved about this in my Jot Script review and it is also true for the Cregle ink. You feel like you can be much more precise when you are writing with a tip the small. This is a great tip.
Note that when the Cregle ink first came out, the tip did not work well with the iPhone 5/5s, nor did it work well with the iPad air (which was released very close to when the Cregle ink came to market). Cregle then adjusted the electronics so that the Cregle ink stylus now being sold works great with both the iPad air and the iPhone 5/5s. This does make me wonder whether there will be an issue with either the Cregle ink or the Adonit Jot Script working with future iPads (and iPhones); hopefully that will not be a problem.
Although the size is similar, the Cregle ink has a different feel than the Adonit Jot Script. The tip on the Jot Script is hard, so it feels very smooth against the iPad screen and gives you the sensation of using a ballpoint pen. The tip on the Cregle ink is rubbery so there is more friction when used against the iPad screen. I actually prefer the feel of the Jot Script against the iPad screen; the decrease in friction makes it easier to write more quickly. But the feel of the Cregle ink is not unlike the feel that you get with most standard styluses against an iPad screen, and indeed the Cregle ink is better because the tip is smaller so there is less surface area. So while I give the edge to the Jot Script, both tips are excellent.
After using the Cregle ink for only a week, I have no personal experience with the durability of the tip, but both Cregle and Adonit talk about how long their tips are expected to last. Cregle says that the tip will last for 2 kilometers of writing distance. A replacement tip is included when you buy the Cregle ink, and you can buy a replacement pack of five tips for $3. Adonit says that the Jot Script's harder tip will last for 120 kilometers of writing distance. So I think it is fair to say that you are likely to need to replace the tip on the Cregle ink from time to time, but you may never need to replace the tip on the Jot Script.
Noise
One of my two main complaints about the Adonit Jot Script is the noise of the harder tip against the iPad screen, especially when you are writing in print instead of script. That led me to actually include a video in my Adonit Jot Script review so that you could hear it for yourself, and longtime readers of iPhone J.D. know that it is pretty rare for me to feel the need to include a video in a review. It isn't an excessive amount of noise, but it is enough for me to feel self-conscious when I am using the Jot Script around others.
The rubbery tip on the Cregle ink is virtually silent to use, similar to the tip of a (larger) standard stylus. Cregle knows that this is a key advantage of its stylus over the Jot Script, and Cregle says on its website: "No Clicking Noise, No Distraction – Built with specialized rubber pen tip, so you can focus on your work without feeling like you are under attack by angry crickets." The "angry crickets" comparison is a little over the top, but it is fair to tout this as an advantage. I love that you don't hear anything when you use the Cregle ink.
Pen clip
It seems odd to focus on something as seemingly minor as the absence of a pen clip on the Adonit Jot Script, but it is a missing feature that really matters. Not only does it mean that it is more awkward to put the Jot Script in a shirt pocket, but it also means that there is nothing to stop the round barrel of the Jot Script from rolling around. Indeed, as I am writing this review, both the Cregle ink and the Jot Script are on my desk, and it is driving me a little batty that the Jot Script keeps rolling around. (There is goes again! Stop that!)
Battery
Both the Cregle ink and the Jot Script are powered by a battery. The Cregle ink uses a AAAA battery, which is smaller than the AAA battery in the Jot Script. That means that the battery doesn't last as long. Cregle advertises up to 11 hours of continuous writing. Adonit doesn't advertise battery life for the Jot Script, but it seems like it lasts more than twice as long as the Cregle ink.
Unfortunately, the smaller battery doesn't result in a thinner stylus. The Cregle Ink is actually slightly fatter than the Jot Script — the Cregle ink has a 12.2 mm diameter; the Jot Script has a diameter of 11.7 — although in practice I didn't notice a difference in size. Both feel fatter than a normal pen or a thin stylus such as the Wacom Bamboo Stylus duo, not so much that they are uncomfortable to use, but enough that you notice it.
Also, a AAAA battery is a little harder to find than a AAA battery, and perhaps as a result is also more expensive. The Cregle ink comes with a replacement AAAA battery, but after only a week of use — albeit more extensive use than normal becuase I have been testing it for this review — the first AAAA battery is already dead.
No Bluetooth
You don't need to use Bluetooth to use either the Cregle ink or the Adonit Jot Script. But with the Jot Script, if you do have Bluetooth turned on, and if you use an app designed to work with the Jot Script (such as Evernote or GoodNotes), your iPad becomes smart enough to ignore unwanted strokes such as your wrist or hand accidentally touching the screen while you are using the stylus. It is a nice feature, although not an essential one. It also has a drawback in that it is somewhat incompatible with multitasking gestures. I discussed this more extensively in my Adonit Jot Script review.
The Cregle ink doesn't use Bluetooth at all, so you don't get any of the special advantages of the Jot Script. But you can also use your multitasking gestures.
Power switch
I don't like the power switch on the Adonit Jot Script. It is flush with the side of the stylus and is hard to find to turn the stylus on — although the Jot Script turns itself off after a short period of non-use so you'll rarely need to find and press the button to turn it off.
There is no power button on the Cregle ink, and instead you switch power on and off by turning the back of the stylus (where the clip is located). The Cregle ink has a small blue light to indicate when the stylus is turned on, and you need to remember to untwist the stylus to turn it off. I actually prefer this approach because the Jot Script is so aggressive with power management that it frequently turns itself off prematurely. Having said that, I suspect one of the reasons that I went through a AAAA battery in only a week is that I leave the Cregle ink on much longer.
Other differences
The Cregle ink (35 g) is heavier than the Jot Script (22 g), which I actually consider a slight advantage because it feels a little more substantial in your hand. But I can just as easily see an argument that lighter is better, and frankly, you won't notice the difference in weight between the two in normal use unless you really think about it and go back and forth between the two. (I was actually surprised to read specifications saying that the Cregle ink weighed over 50% more than the Jot Script because the weight difference didn't feel that substantial, but I checked it on a scale and those are indeed the weights.)
The Cregle ink is smooth and shiny on the barrel, whereas the Jot Script has a brushed metal look and has ridges near the front of the pen to give you more traction when the stylus is in your hand. Both are clear advantages for the Jot Script. The Cregle ink can slip a little in your hand because it is so smooth, plus it shows fingerprints. The slight ridges on the Jot Script keep that stylus in place.
The Cregle ink is also cheaper than the Adonit Jot Script. The Cregle ink is $49, whereas the Jot Script is $74.99. I suppose that, over the long haul, the price of the Cregle ink goes up somewhat because you will be spending more money to replace the battery and you will eventually need replacement tips, which are five for $3.
Cregle ink 2
Although the Cregle ink that I am reviewing is the current model, Cregle is also working on the Cregle ink 2 and has an IndieGoGo page where you can pre-order the next version, expected to ship in August of 2014. Here are the advertised differences:
- The ink 2 uses a AAA battery, which Cregle says provides 19 hours of life versus the 11 hours of the AAAA battery in the ink. That battery will also be easier and cheaper to buy.
- The ink 2 uses a more durable rubber tip, expected to last twice as long as the tip on the ink. So that's 4 kilometers of writing distance instead of 2 kilometers, which I mention mostly because it amuses me to use the word "kilometers" in connection with a pen.
- The ink 2 will be lighter, although Cregle isn't yet saying how much lighter.
- The ink 2 has a power switch on the side. On the IndieGoGo website that button looks similar to the button that I don't like on the Adonit Jot Script, but I'll reserve judgment on it until I have seen it in real life.
- The Cregle ink 2 will ultimately sell for $59, which is $10 more than the $49 Cregle ink, but as of today, you can preorder it now for only $29 if you want it in silver or $38 if you want it in black. (Cregle was selling the first 100 black models for $29, but those are already sold out.)
Here is a chart from the IndieGoGo page comparing the two:
In the world of electronics it is (unfortunately) common to buy a device only to see a new model come out the next month, one that you would have waited for if you had only known what is coming. Because of the IndieGoGo campaign, this is one of those rare instances when you can already see what you will get if you can wait for the second generation model.
Conclusion
I really like the Cregle ink. The fine point tip is fantastic. The Adonit Jot Script tip is even better, but it is also noisier and without a clip it is always rolling around my desk. The Bluetooth features of the Adonit Jot Script are nice, but I don't miss them that much when I am using the Cregle ink, and I'm happy to not have a need to turn off multitasking gestures with the Cregle ink. On the other hand, battery life isn't as good with the Cregle ink, and it will take extra effort to use AAAA batteries instead of AAA.
If you want a stylus with a fine tip, with both the Jot Script and the Cregle ink on the market, you can decide which features matter more to you. I currently find myself leaning more towards the Cregle ink because it is so much quieter than the Jot Script and because it has a clip, but it is a really close decision because the Jot Script tip is so smooth and the battery life is better. If the slight noise and lack of clip don't bother you as much as they bother me, you will probably prefer the Jot Script. Moreover, as much as I like a stylus with a fine tip, I also like to use a stylus with a more narrow barrel for which I never need to worry about running out of power. Thus, I don't think that the Cregle ink will completely replace my use of the Wacom Bamboo Stylus duo.
And finally, if you don't mind waiting until later this year to have one, you should consider the IndieGoGo page for the Cregle Ink 2 to get the better battery life. There are no guarantees on the ship date, so you certainly could have to wait even past August, but the preorder price of $29 sounds like a good deal compared to the $74.99 for the Jot Script.
Click here to get the Cregle ink from Cregle ($49)
Click here to get the Cregle ink 2 from IndieGoGo ($29 and up)